Piaggio Carnaby reliability

First registered 2007–2013 · 1,073 MOT tests

Less reliable than average

The Piaggio Carnaby fails its MOT 19% more often than comparable cars.

95% range: 5–34% more often. Compared with comparable cars of the same age, mileage and year of first registration, on 1,073 first MOT tests of vehicles first registered 2007–2013.

Relative fail rate 1.19 (95% range 1.05–1.34); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles

fails less oftenmore often

80%
pass their MOT first time (78.0%–82.7%)
180
vehicles MOT-tested, 11 still on the road
1,500 miles
typical miles a year
1%
reached 100,000 miles

MOT pass rate by age

Share of first MOT tests each year (not retests) that passed with no failure items.

The dashed line is all cars of the same age, whatever their mileage. The verdict above also matches mileage and year of first registration, so the two can differ; pass rate by mileage compares like with like.

Piaggio Carnaby95% rangeAll cars of the same age
60%70%80%90%100% 34567 Age at MOT (years) 60%70%80%90%100% 34567 Age at MOT (years)
Show as a table: pass rate by age
AgePass first time95% rangeAll cars of the same ageTests
387.1%80.5%–91.6%86.2%139
484.7%77.6%–89.9%83.7%131
583.6%76.0%–89.1%80.1%122
677.9%69.7%–84.3%76.4%122
788.7%81.3%–93.4%72.7%106

Buying a high-mileage Piaggio Carnaby

Too few MOT tests at 100,000+ miles for a high-mileage verdict.

First-time MOT pass rate at each mileage. The dashed line is what comparable cars with the same mileage, age and year of first registration achieve, so the gap between the lines is down to the model, not to how old or well used the cars are.

Not enough tests across mileage bands to draw this chart.

Best and worst years

How often vehicles first registered in each year fail, against comparable cars of the same age and mileage.

Fails less often than comparable carsFails more often
0.670.801.01.25 200720082009 Year of first registration 0.670.801.01.25 200720082009 Year of first registration

Bars below the line: cars first registered that year fail less often than comparable cars of the same age and mileage. Scale is relative (1.0 = same).

Show as a table: fail rate by year of first registration
First registeredRelative fail rateTests
20071.09369
20081.43377
20091.13253

What fails

Share of first MOT tests with at least one failure item in each area; 5.2% had a dangerous defect. “vs comparable cars” compares with comparable cars of the same age, mileage and year of first registration.

AreaMOTs failed on itvs comparable cars
Lights & electrics +17%
Brakes -6%
Tyres & wheels +43%
Suspension +68%
Steering +51%
Seat belts & airbags +409%
Registration plate & VIN -41%
Exhaust & emissions -17%
Fuel system +140%
Windscreen & mirrors +337%
Engine & leaks +462%

Most common MOT failures

  1. 1Tyre tread depth is below minimum requirements of 1.0mm · Tyres & wheels2.9% of MOTs
  2. 2Headlamp aim too high · Lights & electrics2.6% of MOTs
  3. 3Reflector on motorcycle missing · Lights & electrics1.1% of MOTs
  4. 4Reflector missing · Lights & electrics1.0% of MOTs
  5. 5Shock absorber seal failed and leaking oil · Suspension1.0% of MOTs
  6. 6Brake pad less than 1.0 mm thick · Brakes0.9% of MOTs
  7. 7Reflector on motorcycle obscured · Lights & electrics0.9% of MOTs
  8. 8Riders seat insecure · Seat belts & airbags0.9% of MOTs
  9. 9Stop lamp remains on when the brake is released · Brakes0.8% of MOTs
  10. 10Stop lamp does not illuminate immediately a brake applies · Brakes0.8% of MOTs

Other Piaggio models

Older, higher-mileage vehicles pass less often, so each verdict compares a vehicle with others of the same age and mileage. A newer one can pass more often and still rate worse.

ModelYearsMOTsPass first timevs comparable (1.0 = same)Verdict
Piaggio Vespa 1996–2022 353k 83% Relative fail rate 1.06 (95% range 1.06–1.07); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.06 Worse
Piaggio Zip 1996–2019 85k 74% Relative fail rate 1.64 (95% range 1.62–1.66); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.64 Much worse
Piaggio NRG 1997–2017 40k 69% Relative fail rate 1.99 (95% range 1.96–2.02); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.99 Much worse
Piaggio PX 125 (vespa) 1999–2009 36k 84% Relative fail rate 0.96 (95% range 0.94–0.98); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 0.96 Average
Piaggio MP3 2006–2023 32k 85% Relative fail rate 0.86 (95% range 0.84–0.88); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 0.86 Better
Piaggio PX 200 E 1993–2003 30k 89% Relative fail rate 0.67 (95% range 0.65–0.69); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 0.67 Much better
Piaggio ET2 1997–2005 25k 77% Relative fail rate 1.47 (95% range 1.44–1.51); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.47 Much worse
Piaggio X9 2000–2008 24k 79% Relative fail rate 1.27 (95% range 1.24–1.30); 1.00 = same as comparable vehicles 1.27 Worse